ports/160481: devel/icu: Errors in total: 1. TestCompilerRTTI UObjectTest utility CLANG build failure

[Hartmann, O.]

On 09/09/11 22:16, Sunpoet Po-Chuan Hsieh wrote:
> On Mon, Sep 05, 2011 at 09:18:25PM +0200, Hartmann, O. wrote:
>> On 09/05/11 18:16, Sunpoet Po-Chuan Hsieh wrote:
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> The failure is not limited to clang. It will also occur if you use gcc. :)
>>>
>>> excerpt from ${WRKSRC}/test/intltest/uobjtest.cpp:
>>>
>>>      NumberFormat *nf = NumberFormat::createInstance("de", errorCode);
>>>
>>> ...
>>>
>>>      if (&typeid(*nf) == NULL || typeid(*nf) == typeid(UObject) || typeid(*nf) == typeid(Format) ||
>>>          typeid(*nf) != typeid(DecimalFormat) || typeid(*nf) == typeid(ChoiceFormat) ||
>>>          typeid(*nf) == typeid(emptySet)
>>>      ) {
>>>          errln("typeid(NumberFormat) failed");
>>>      }
>>>
>>> The failure was raised by typeid(*nf) != typeid(DecimalFormat).
>>> However, according to [1], I think it should be ==, not !=.
>>> That means you could safely ignore this. :)
>>>
>>> [1] http://icu-project.org/apiref/icu4c/classNumberFormat.html
>>>
>>> Regards,
>> Hello.
>> Using the legacy system's gcc 4.2, the port devel/icu compiles and
>> installs without error.
>> Using clang, the port is not installed properly.
>>
>> Using a portmaster -f xorg, which triggers the build of all ports
>> neccessary for xorg ports
>> matched by the pattern "xorg" results in a stop of the build
>> process. I can not test further
>> the proper build of the X11 subsystem without excluding explicitely
>> devel/icu (amongst others).
>>
>> The error occured does not seem to be "obvious" to me, so reporting
>> this issue by a PR seems the proper
>> way.
>>
>> Can this be fixed so that clang compiles the port and portmaster
>> installes the port properly?
>>
>> Regards,
>> Oliver
> Please try the patch at http://people.freebsd.org/~sunpoet/icu.patch
> Thanks.
>
> Regards,

Hello.

Doesn't work. After application of the suggested patch I receive this:

    } OK:   rbnfp
    csdet {
       ConstructionTest {
       } OK:   ConstructionTest
       UTF8Test {
       } OK:   UTF8Test
       UTF16Test {
       } OK:   UTF16Test
       C1BytesTest {
       } OK:   C1BytesTest
       InputFilterTest {
       } OK:   InputFilterTest
       DetectionTest {
       } OK:   DetectionTest  (68ms)
       IBM424Test {
       } OK:   IBM424Test
       IBM420Test {
       } OK:   IBM420Test
       Ticket6394Test {
       } OK:   Ticket6394Test
    } OK:   csdet  (70ms)
    spoof {
       TestSpoofAPI {
       } OK:   TestSpoofAPI
       TestSkeleton {
       } OK:   TestSkeleton
       TestAreConfusable {
       } OK:   TestAreConfusable
       TestInvisible {
       } OK:   TestInvisible
       testConfData {
       } OK:   testConfData  (76ms)
       testBug8654 {
       } OK:   testBug8654
    } OK:   spoof  (76ms)
    bidi {
       TestBidiTest {
       } OK:   TestBidiTest  (250ms)
    } OK:   bidi  (250ms)

--------------------------------------
Errors in total: 1.
             TestCompilerRTTI
          UObjectTest
       utility

--------------------------------------
Elapsed Time: 00:01:38.808
*** Error code 1

Stop in /usr/ports/devel/icu.
*** Error code 1

Stop in /usr/ports/devel/icu.